Itâ€™s clear that Thanksgiving is an â€œissueâ€ for many Baalei Teshuvah. In addition to Neil Harrisâ€™ Being Thankful for Thanksgiving, the issue has come up in numerous posts and comments. We have highlighted some of those posts and comments below.
In Can You Really Get Everything You Want at Aliceâ€™s Restaurant?, Rachel Adler sought advice on her first Thanksgiving in someone elseâ€™s non-kosher home:
â€œThanksgiving, on the other hand, was one of the few holidays that I could spend at home with my family. For the past 10 or so years, weâ€™ve hosted our extended family for Thanksgiving, with our cousins from New Jersey, California, and sometimes even Guatemala coming to the meal. Usually there are over 20 people. This was convenient when I started keeping kosher, since my parents started keeping a kosher house and no one had to make any special arrangements for meâ€¦ I have a younger cousin, who just got accepted to Washington University in St. Louis, where sheâ€™ll be going next year. Sheâ€™s among the cousins who usually visit us for Thanksgiving. This year, however, her parents want to host Thanksgiving since this is the first time sheâ€™s been away from her family and they want her to be able to go home for her first school break. This is understandable, but when my mom told me this yesterday, I asked â€œWhat am I going to eat? And what about Shabbat?â€â€¦ My cousins donâ€™t have a kosher kitchen and, as far as I know, they donâ€™t even know how to keep kosher (besides the basics of no milk and meat) since they, unlike my parents, were never raised keeping kosherâ€¦ I know that this would be a good opportunity for me to do a kiddush Hashem if I can figure out a way to make this work without causing strife. I really love my cousins. I just have no clue what to do. Any advice?”
Some advice from the comments:
If your aunt is open to you bringing your own food that is what I usually do in these circumstances. In my experience, it is better to discuss this directly with your hosts than have your parents advocate for you. Thanksgiving is usually celebrated Thursday afternoon, right? Could you be with your family Wednesday and Thursday night and then go to an observant family for Shabbat? â€¦I have been doing stuff like this with my family for several years, and I have found that there is usually a way to compromise. I think you are taking a great attitude by thinking of the potential for kiddush Hashem.
As an aside, the kosher traveler can now find packaged kosher items in virtually every supermarket, convenience store, and Wal-Mart in the US. La Briute self-heating TV dinners are available in some stores and on-line (check www.labriutemeals.com )
Out of Town:
Thanksgiving can be a difficult holiday for BTs. I know my parents were very offended when I wouldnâ€™t eat the turkey at their house when I started becoming frum. I would definitely agree that you should talk to the hosts in advance and warn them that you will be bringing your own food. Those La Briute meals are pretty good and I think they even have a turkey one. Another option is to either buy or make a meal at home, freeze it, then heat it up at their house. Or, maybe you could volunteer to bring one of the side dishes, that way you will have something to eat that everyone else will eat, then just bring your own turkey or whatever. Good luck!
I have the same problem as wellâ€¦
I would first discuss the situation with the appropriate family members. If you are comfortable, discuss the issue with the hosts. Since you love them and I am sure they love you, they will be happy to help come up with a compromise. This is a â€˜betterâ€™ situation than one where the hosts refuse to compromise at all. I have done this in the past, and I have found it to be extremely helpful as it eliminates surprises and opens the lines of communication and sets expectations. Especially since Thanksgiving is an eating-oriented holiday, no one would want you to be left out of the eating.
Determine what is the most that you can do on your end. Bring a cold salad, plates & utensils, dessert, appetizers, etc. Do the max that you can do. When we went to a non-kosher house for Thanksgiving last year, I brought appetizers, side dishes, and dessert to ensure that we would at least have something to eat!
Include your family in your Shabbat plans. Since itâ€™s also a family-oriented holiday, maybe your relatives would like to â€˜doâ€™ Shabbat with you, or whatever. See what their thoughts are. Maybe you can organize something! (which may be a relief for the hostess from all the cooking)
Now may be the time to be creativeâ€¦ It is obvious that you are willing to do that which maintains family harmony while also staying true to yourself. Being honest will help with that. Good luck!
Something that is definitely worth doing is really learning about kashrut, the foundations behind the halacha, and the very practical end of kashrut (what must have a heksher and what products donâ€™t need a heksher, what is considered sharp/hot and what is not, steam, kashering burners, ovens, microwaves, bishul, and more).
As it is said, knowledge is power, and with some ingenuity, resources, and knowledge, it is more than possible to create kosher meals in a non-kosher home without upsetting everyone.
Goodluck and enjoy Palo Alto. The frum community there is very nice.
Ah – Thanksgiving, the holiday of the BT :) . At least it is for our families.
Neither my, nor my husband have parents with kosher kitchens, yet we have managed to make a totally kosher Thanksgiving meal in their homes. Self cleaning ovens, tin pans, disposable plates and â€™silverwareâ€™ with maybe a few pots brought in. If your relatives are game, it can be done. This also prevents the issue of â€˜why do you have different foodâ€™ and â€˜what, did I contaminate your food with my fork?â€™ and so on.
Shayna spoke about how she â€œlost Thanksgivingâ€ in Painfully Cutting Ties to the Past and the commentors offered support and some insight on the halachic parameters of the holiday.
Thanksgiving was supposed to remain a lifeline with my Before Teshuva world. At first, I stubbornly held on to New Yearâ€™s, defiantly rationalizing that we live by the secular calendar, too. But in truth, Iâ€™d long been uncomfortable with the idea that we kept our dates by their relation to the death of the Christian deity. (Thatâ€™s pretty weird for a supposedly secular country.) Halloween was no great loss with the introduction of Purim. And, on Fourth of July, I usually serve my family something sweet and patriotically decorated and take the kids to a quiet spot to watch fireworks.
Then I lost Thanksgiving.
Rabbaim have poskuned that Thanksgiving has non-Jewish roots. Someone unhelpfully provided us with a pamphlet spelling out the problem. And since no one in the kidsâ€™ yeshivas does it, and, more importantly, Iâ€™ve lost my rebellious spirit in the realization that no matter how much I bristle, the frum way is usually best, after allâ€¦we donâ€™t celebrate Thanksgiving either.
And now I feel a loss on that late November Thursday. I miss the politically uncorrect Pilgrims, stuffing, and pumpkin pie with whipped cream. Milchig.
Some advice from the comments:
It is by no means a foregone conclusion that Thanksgiving is a â€œtreifâ€ holiday. There was a diversity of opinion among gedolim in the last century on the subject. Rabbi Michael Broyde wrote an excellent analysis of the subject which you can read here http://www.tfdixie.com/special/thanksg.htm
There are enough things baalei teshuva must give up without going overboard and giving up things we donâ€™t have to.
See my response to another post on a similar topic on the suitability of Thanksgiving for BTâ€™s!
Also, I think that some ties must be cut, and other ties do not need to be, or should not be. Here one needs the advice of a posek who â€œgets itâ€ and who is familiar with your family situation in most cases. We should strive to make â€œyessesâ€ wherever possible.
This year my parents could not make it,so we were spared some stress with non-Jewish cousins. But my wife still made some traditional dishes, and we talked about Squanto and mekoras hatov.
On the other hand, she refused to make me roast chestnuts, which my Dad always insists on- oh well.
Great comment. I wholeheartedly agree with the need to find a possek or rav who is familiar with oneâ€™s particular background and avoid making decisions, especially regarding restrictions, without first asking (we will be discussing the issue of finding a rav a sometime over the next few weeks). Sorry about the chestnuts, Melech.
Shayna – I think that the fact that no other kids in the yeshiva are celebrating is not, in and of itself, a reason not to do it. Sure, we feel peer pressure and we donâ€™t want our kids to be singled out or made fun of. At the same time, we also need to teach are kids the importance of family and permissive individuality.
We are perhaps one of a handful of families in our school that actually has a Thanksgiving meal (my mother made a mean turkey this year, delicious!). At the same time, I think we would certainly be considered â€œmore to the rightâ€ than the overwhelming majority of families in the school when it comes to many other social and parenting issues. My wife and I are constantly struggling to strike the balance where our kids understand that just because we donâ€™t allow a particular activity until a certain age and their friendsâ€™ parents do doesnâ€™t mean that we are better or frumer than they are. I think that equips them to handle the â€œpeer pressureâ€ when we do things that others donâ€™t, i.e. Thanksgiving.
Teaching tolerance isnâ€™t easy but as BTs that has got to be a priority especially when half of us are here complaining about how many sectors of the FFB world are intolerant of us.
All the talk of turkey and sushi on this site is making hungry!
Hey, BT! Lighten up! FYI, what we now observe as Secular New Yearâ€™s Day – 1 January – was observed in the ancient world before the birth of Christianity, and was coâ€“opted by the Church. The reason Christmas Day falls eight days before the New Year has to do with making the beirth of the year correspond with the circumcision of Baby J. As to Thanksgiving, one way to look at it is to say it has Christian Roots. Another way is to recognize that its roots really lie in the quest for relgious freedom. I believe it was the Chofetz Chaim who exhorted his own children to go to America, stating that the future of religious Judaism would be there. The Founders of this country were more religion-oriented and G-d oriented than they were Christian oriented. They were Deists and Freemasons, for whom belief in a Deity superseded adherence to a religion. To this day, there is no country on earth more positively disposed towards religious observance, and more religiously tolerant. You couldnâ€™t be a BT in most other countries in the world – not throughout human history, and not even today – without exposing yourself to physical danger. Here, all you have to worry about is embarrassing yourself by not knowing when to stand up and sit down during the services. Are you going to pasken yourself out of recognizing the blessing that HaKadosh Baruch Hu has given us, to be able to be BTRs in the world today? Or are you, like me, going to embrace the one holiday that celebrates G-d and belief, and America all at once?
Rivkah cut to the chase with her American Holidays â€“ Thanksgiving Survival Guide, really short version
For the last several years I have not had to face being around my family during any of the chagim because I had lived in Israel. Saying no to attending family holidays, for many people it is an extremely difficult burden to face. How do you say no when it is family? But how can you say yes to the Pesach Family Seder that lasts about 15 minutes and the Rosh Hashanah Meal both First and Second Night that isnâ€™t kosher or Sukkot Chol Hamoed Lunch that isnâ€™t in a Sukkah even when it isnâ€™t raining. It is so hard because we love our family and we bend over backwards not wanting to alienate them from frumkite, chas vâ€™shalom. But lets face itâ€¦knowing that the chagim are all about our relationship with HaKadosh Baruch-Hu and we just canâ€™t get â€œthereâ€ to the loftiest of places in a home where there isnâ€™t Kiddushaâ€¦or at least the brand of Kiddusha we need especially on a Yom Tov.
So how do you get out of the holiday of Thanksgiving? It never falls on a Shabbatâ€¦ok and it isnâ€™t a Yom Tovâ€¦ no problem there. The truth is, at least for me, Turkey-Day is the one holiday I donâ€™t want or need to â€œget out ofâ€. This year, for the first time in many years, I was able to and did attend the Family Thanksgiving Dinner. So here is my Survivors Guide, really short version, to spending Thanksgiving (or July 4th, Memorial Day, Labor Day, New Years Day fill in the blank __ Day) with your family.
It is really important that you are able to do the most important thing on Thanksgiving and that is of course EAT. Waking up early on Thanksgiving, my kosher turkey went in the oven. Quickly the house was filled with all the smells of my childhood. I made everything I needed to feel good at the tableâ€¦ I was able to sit next to my cousins (of course still at the childrenâ€™s table) and stuff my belly with yummy Thanksgiving delicacies. I even had enough leftovers at home in the fridge to feel very American on â€œBlack Fridayâ€. The mashed potatoes were my â€œcontributionâ€ to the cornucopia feast. Of course they were parve. I couldnâ€™t bring the traditional buttery potatoes to set along side the table of turkey and spiral-cut-you-know-what! At the end of the evening as we all reclined in our chairs, everyone wanted to know how I made the yummy dilled mashed fluffy stuff. They were all stunned to hear about my secret to make them creamy with out milk or butter (margarine and light mayonnaise). Smiling to myself I thought of my own theory. They tasted so yummy because they were the only kosher thing on the tableâ€¦of course other than my shiny aluminum pan, double wrapped foil peeled back filled with all the essentials: half a turkey breast, a mini portion of yams with marshmallow, challah stuffing, string bean casserole and of course parve mashed potatoes. FYI â€¦ you can follow the Libbyâ€™s Pumpkin Pie recipe on the label but instead of condensed milk, replace with soy milk and Richâ€™s cream frozen.
Some advice from the comments:
You did all that on a Thursday night? I am impressed. Did you have turkey for Shabbos?
Thanksgiving is the last holiday one should try to â€œget out ofâ€. In my motherâ€™s extened family there are/were two huge gathering each year that go back at least 2 generations; Pesach Sedar and Thanksgiving. Both gatherings included 3 to 4 generations, often 50 or more people.
As soon as I became frum the Pesach sedar had to go as it was not even kosher let along pesadik. It just wasnâ€™t an option.
Thanksgiving was another story. Since driving and housing were not an issue, I saw no reason not to continue attending this annual â€œseudahâ€ in order to maintain ties with my extended family. It was usually held in a treif restaraunt and for a few years my mother would order special meals for us (my two siblings and I, and later my wife). Later on we decided to forgo the special meals as they were more hassle than they were worth and we realized the main thing was just to be together with family, not the eating.
Iâ€™ve been doing Thanksgiving at my Motherâ€™s the past 15 or so years (thatâ€™s a lot of Turkey!) Iâ€™m fortunate in the fact that my Mother is now Shomer Shabbos (a story for another time) and kashrus is not an issue.
If youâ€™re going somewhere where you canâ€™t eat, make sure to bring something that you can eat and that everyone else can eat as well!
Conversation is just as importnat as food. O.K., almost as important as food. O.K., conversation is important too. Thanksgiving is just not the time to synopsize the daf for your non-frum cousin. Neither is it the time to sit on the side with your head buried in a sefer. Try to find common ground. If you follow sports and your family does too, voila. Reminiscences of childhood days may work (if you have good ones). Bottom line is to give it some thought before you get there.
Hey, one of my favorite topics! I once heard an FFB make a crack to a very chashuv Rav, â€œJews donâ€™t do Thanksgiving, we thank Hashem _every_ day.â€ The Rav- very insightful and knew who he was speaking to said, â€œSo whatâ€™s wrong with taking one day and doing it a little more?â€
In my family, Thanksgiving persists because it provides few challenges. True, it has to be at our house so we can ensure the kashrus, but thatâ€™s not a challenge to my non-frum family and some of their non-Jewish spouses. We get together, eat, thank G-d for obvious blessings, sit around and talk, and donâ€™t watch any football since we donâ€™t own a TV. Then they all leave.
My own Rav has told me on many occaisions that BTâ€™s have to work hard to find â€œyessesâ€ since so much of what we do becomes â€œnoâ€™sâ€ for them. Thanksgiving is a very easy â€œyes.â€
Except when my wife served turkey on shabbos, my son, then 5 or 6, â€œposkenedâ€ â€œYouâ€™re not allowed to serve leftovers from a goyishe holiday for shabbos!â€
Thatâ€™s BBTâ€™s, folks.
Oh, and thereâ€™s no kiruv either.
Originally published on 11/18/2006