Rabbi Ben Tzion Shafier
And he said, â€œWho placed you as a judge and ruler above us. Will you say to kill us as you killed the Egyptian.â€ And Moshe feared, and he said, â€œNow the matter is knownâ€. Shemos 2:14
When Moshe came of age, he went out to visit his brothers â€” to share in their suffering. What he saw caused him great anguish. The oppression, subjugation, and cruelty were present wherever he looked. The next day, Moshe again â€œwent out to his brothers,â€ this time he witnessed two Jews engaged in mortal combat. One was standing over the other in an attempt to kill him. Moshe called out, â€œWicked one, why are you hitting your friend?!â€ This put an end to the bloodshed.
However, Mosheâ€™s intervention wasnâ€™t appreciated. Quite the opposite, their response was, â€œWho appointed you to be a judge over us? Are you going to kill us as you killed the Mitzri yesterday?â€ The Medrash tells us this was actually a threat. The day before Moshe killed a Mitzri guard, who was mercilessly whipping an innocent Jew. The two Jews who were fighting had seen this, and they now warned Moshe that they were going to report him to the authorities for rebelling against the kingâ€”which they did.
When Pharaoh heard that the heir apparent had openly challenged the law of the land and defended a Jew against his master, he brought Moshe to trial for tyranny. In the end, Moshe had to flee Mitzraim at the risk of his life.
Interestingly, when Moshe first heard their threat his response was, â€œNow the matter is known.â€ Rashi explains that for many years, Moshe had a question: â€œWhy is it that of all the seventy nations, the Jews are singled out for oppression?â€ Once he saw that there were talebearers amongst the Jews, he understood why this nation was so fated.
This Rashi is very difficult to understand for a number of reasons. 1. Moshe witnessed two people threatening to report him. Two individuals donâ€™t define a nation. 2. Didnâ€™t all the other nations speak Loshon Harah as well? 3. Even if it were true that entire Jewish People were gossipers, what is so egregious about this sin that an entire nation should suffer cruel, brutal subjugation?
The answer to this can best be understood with a moshol.
Making a hole in my cabin
Imagine a man boards a transatlantic ocean liner carrying an electric saw. Late at night, one of the shipâ€™s personnel hears a distinct rattling noise coming from the manâ€™s cabin. The crewmember knocks on the door â€“ no answer. The noise continues. He knocks again. Still no response. Fearing danger, he kicks in the door, only to see the passenger standing poised against the shipâ€™s hull, electric saw in hand, attempting to cut through the skin of the ship. The crewmember screams out, â€œStop it! What are you doing?â€
The passenger calmly responds, â€œSir, do you see this boarding pass in my hand? Do you see that it states that I have the right to a private cabin? Why are you disturbing me? Here I am, in the privacy of my own compartment, doing what I want. If I want to drill a hole in my room, that is my choice. I have paid for this cabin and I have the prerogative to do whatever I want here. Leave me alone.â€
The Chofetz Chaim compares this situation to the Jewish people. He explains that our nation is one unit â€“ irrevocably tied together in a common fate. What happens to one affects another. The state of each individual impacts the whole. There is no such concept as one person doing what he wants in the privacy of his home and not affecting the Klal. But more than this, we are one body. Where the tail goes, the head canâ€™t be far behind. When Moshe saw the levels that the tail had sunk to, he knew that the body of the nation couldnâ€™t be that high. This single action shed light onto the madregah of the people.
The Chofetz Chaim explains that the antidote to Loshon Harah is â€œloving my neighbor.â€ If I, in fact, viewed him as connected to me, I would never speak negatively about him. It would be like bad-mouthing myself.
This seems to be the answer to this Rashi. The Jewish nation is one. If such an incident of vicious slander could occur, it reflected on the state of nation. If the people had been on a higher level, this could not have transpired. It meant that the nation as a whole was lacking in a key ingredient â€“ a sense of common destiny, a sense of brotherhood, the sense that I am one with my fellow Jew. And that is why the nation deserved to be punished.
More is expected from the Chosen Nation
If the people involved were the French, the Germans, or the ancient Greeks, this wouldnâ€™t have been an issue. They are a people by circumstance, born of common lineage and brought up in a common land, but there ends the connection. The Jewish people are different. As children of Avrohom, Yitzchak, and Yaakov, we share a common heritage and destiny. We are bound together for eternity. We are one.
For that reason, when Moshe witnessed this act of cruel gossip mongering, he took it as a sign of the health of the nation. If the bottom has sunk this low, the head canâ€™t be that much higher. He then understood why it is that the Jews deserved such treatment. If any other nation degrades one another, there isnâ€™t much fault found with them. If a member of the chosen people speaks badly about another, that bodes serious consequences. We are held to a higher standard.
This concept is a powerful lesson to us about the unity of the Jewish people, our common destiny, and the power of each individual to impact the whole.
Rabbi Shafier is the founder of the Shmuz.com â€“ The Shmuz is an engaging, motivating shiur that deals with real life issues.
All of the Shmuzin are available free of charge at www.theShmuz.com or on the Shmuz App for iphone or Android. Simply text the word â€œTheShmuzâ€ to the number 313131 and a link will be sent to your phone to download the App.