Rav Itamar Shwarz, the author of the Bilvavi Mishkan Evneh
Download this and a number of other Drashos on Sukkos
Sukkah and the Four Species â€“ The Dual Natures of Man
On Sukkos, we have two mitzvos: to sit in the sukkah, and to shake the Four Species. These two mitzvos represent the two sides of man. The Four Species, which we shake around and move, represent how man is always in movement. We are full of various retzonos (desires), and all of these desires are a kind of movement. The mitzvah of sitting in the sukkah represents a totally different side to us. In a sukkah, we donâ€™t move; we sit there.
Hashem is mainly called by two names. The lower name of Hashem is â€œadonoyâ€ – He is our adon, our master. This refers to how we serve him with the mitzvos. The higher name of Hashem is the four-letter name of havayah, and this refers to the simple recognition of His existence. The two names of Hashem reflect the two sides of our lifeâ€™s mission. On one hand, we â€œmoveâ€ constantly by doing all the mitzvos. This is how relate to Hashem as our Master, Whom we serve; that He is adonoy. But the inner essence to our life is that we recognize his existence and integrate our own existence as a part of Hashem. This is how we relate to Hashem with his higher name, havayah. It is the deeper part of our life.
The fact that Hashem exists is not just a fact about life, but it is something which we can connect ourselves to. The mitzvah of sitting in the Sukkah is entirely about this concept â€“ to sit in Hashemâ€™s Presence, with no need to move around, and instead to connect to Hashemâ€™s Endlessness.
In this discussion, the intention is not merely to say a nice dvar Torah for Sukkos, but rather, to define the very essence of Sukkos: accessing our innermost point of our self â€“ our point of non-movement â€“ when we integrate with Hashem. It is also a concept that has ramifications to our entire life. It is the way how we can prepare for the future, when we will sit in the Sukkah made of the leviathan skin.
The depth of our Avodah on Sukkos is to combine the two sides of mankind and integrate them together: the Four Species, which represents our mitzvos\movement, and the mitzvah of sitting in the Sukkah, which represents our recognition of Hashem\non-movement.
Our Actual Essence Vs. The Outer Layers of the Self
We will try to explain this as much as Hashem allows us to understand it.
The most complicating thing in the world is our self. Anything else we recognize are all superficial realities â€“ such as our house, the block we live on, the country we live in, even the world; itâ€™s all an external, superficial kind of recognition. If this is all a person knows of, then he lives a superficial kind of existence â€“ he lives on the outside world. He is thinking all the time about things that are outside of himself. The clothing we wear is not either a part of who we are.
When a person begins to look for his inner essence, he is apt to think that he â€œisâ€ what he â€œdoes.â€ He identifies himself based on his actions, his emotions, and his thoughts.
For example, a person has an affinity to do chessed (kindness), so he thinks of himself as a â€œgood personâ€ since he sees that he is drawn towards doing good things. When he has to reprimand his children sometimes, he feels horrible inside, because now he thinks heâ€™s a â€œbad personâ€ by having to act cruel to them.
If a person is deeper, he knows that there is more to himself than the actions he does. He is aware of his thoughts â€“ and he identifies himself based on whatâ€™s going on in his mind. Yet this is erroneous as well, because a person is not his thoughts either.
Our actions, our emotions, and our thoughts are just outer layers that cover over our essence. They are like garments that clothe our soul. But there is more to who we are than our actions, emotions, and thoughts.
How can a person identify who he really is?
To be frank, there is almost no one who truly knows who he is, and there is almost no one as well who really recognizes Hashem. If a person doesnâ€™t know he really is, he canâ€™t either recognize Hashem!
There are many people who are searching to find Hashem. But, it is written â€œFrom my flesh I see G-dâ€; in other words, we need to know who we are in order to be able to recognize Hashem.
Only By Recognizing Our Self Can We Recognize Hashem
We will expand more upon these words, because it is a very fundamental concept which needs to be understood well.
There is no person who has no self-knowledge of himself whatsoever; all of us know ourselves to a certain extent, besides for those who have become mentally ill (may G-d have mercy upon them). But the way we understand ourselves is superficial: we recognize ourselves based on the outer parts of our self, such as our actions, our conversations, our emotions, and our thoughts. These are outer layers to our soul â€“ garments that cover over our actual soul â€“ and therefore these factors are not a real way to identify ourselves.
When a person only has a superficial understanding of himself, he will in turn have a superficial relationship towards G-d. It is written, â€œFrom my flesh, I see G-dâ€, so if a person doesnâ€™t properly recognize his own â€œfleshâ€, his real self, he wonâ€™t come to really identify Hashem either. As a result, he will never form a deep bond with the Creator, because he doesnâ€™t really conceptualize the Creatorâ€™s existence in the first place.
We can compare this to a person who wishes to grind flour but he has no home appliance to grind it with. The â€œIâ€ in a person is a tool for one to recognize the Creator of the World, because â€œThe Holy One and Yisrael are oneâ€. If someone recognizes his own Yisrael, the Jew inside himself â€“ his beginning, for Yisrael is called â€œthe beginningâ€ (see Rashi Beraishis 1:1), then he can come to recognize the beginning of his own beginning, which is the Creator; the Ultimate Beginning. But if a person never got to his own beginning, and he only knows of branches from his beginning â€“ his various abilities â€“ then not only is he missing a bond with the Creator, but he is missing his own Jew within. The essence of the Jew is that he is a Yisrael; thus, if a Jew does not recognize that he is Yisrael deep down in his soul, he is missing self-recognition.
How indeed can a Jew attain self-recognition? It is not written in any sefer\book in the entire world. A book is an outer entity, and thus it impossible for the actual â€œIâ€ to be described in any book! If the â€œIâ€ could be written about in a book, that would be releasing the â€œIâ€ from its inner chamber out into the open world, and that itself is impossible.
The only one who can reveal the â€œIâ€ is Hashem Himself. â€œI am Hashem your G-d.â€ The word anochi (I) stands for the words ana nafshai kesavis yehavis, â€œI Myself can write this.â€ In other words, the only one who can write about the â€œIâ€ is Hashem. Hashem has given us the tool in how we can recognize Him: the more we recognize our self, the more we recognize Him. If we have only a superficial self-recognition, then our recognition of Hashem will also be superficial. If we recognize what our essence is, then we will be able to recognize the essence of Hashem.
The Torah begins with the letter beis, in the word Beraishis. The Ten Commandments began with the letter aleph, in the word â€œAnochi.â€ The depth of this is that Hashem reveals Himself in the letter Aleph, which is the beginning letter. If we come to our letter â€œalephâ€ in our soul â€“ our point of beginning â€“ then we will be able to come to the total level of Aleph, the Absolute One, the Absolute Beginning â€“ the One who existed, exists and will always exist: the Creator. But if man doesnâ€™t recognize who he is, then he wonâ€™t be able to recognize his Creator.
What is the most hidden thing in Creation? Hashemâ€™s Name is never pronounced. Whenever the Name of Havayah is used in the Torah, we read it as â€œAdonoy.â€ The actual â€œIâ€ of Hashem, even when it is written, is never read. And when we do read a name of Hashem, it is not written there. This is not only a fact about reading Torah. It a perspective to have on Creation, a perception of our soul.
There in inner kind of writing of our soul which cannot be read. If we could read it, we would be in the state of Moshiachâ€™s times, which we are not in right now. When we all will be able to pronounce the Name of Havayah, Moshiach will come. Nowadays, only a few individuals are allowed to use the Name of Havayah. Our Avodah is for us to reach the Name of Havayah of Hashem, which we do not currently recognize.
We usually relate to Hashem with the fact that we must do the mitzvos He commanded us with. However, there is an inner aspect to our relationship towards Hashem which we start out being unaware of, and we must discover it. It is the fact that we are not just servants of our Master, but rather, our whole existence is connected with Him.
That is the difference between the lower name of Hashem, Adonoy, and the higher name of Hashem, which is Havayah. The lower name, Adonoy, represents how we must do the mitzvos, for He is our Master. The name of Adonoy implies that our relationship with Him is dependent on the actions we do. The higher name, Havayah, reflects that we are all integrated with Hashem, regardless of what we do or not, because the connection is intrinsic. â€œA Jew who sins is still a Jew.â€
The point of havayah â€“ our true existence, in which we are integrated with Hashem â€“ is the point that is hidden away deep in the soul. When we do the mitzvos, it builds the outer layers of our soul, but it doesnâ€™t build the point of havayah in the soul.
When a person performs a mitzvah, he is doing an action. The root of all action is the power of ratzon â€“ the will. The will represents manâ€™s nature to always be in movement; ratzon comes from the word ratz, to â€œrunâ€, to move. If a person considers his ratzon to be the deepest part of himself, he identifies himself with the power of movement, of action. He is at the level of the Four Species, which move in all six directions of the world â€“ but he hasnâ€™t yet gotten to his own self. He hasnâ€™t yet gotten to the â€œSukkahâ€ inside himself â€“ to the â€œYisraelâ€ inside him, his true â€œI.â€
With a poor sense of self-recognition, even a person sitting in the Sukkah doesnâ€™t grasp what the concept of Sukkah is. Although it appears as if heâ€™s reached the point of non-movement, because heâ€™s sitting in the Sukkah â€“ heâ€™s only there physically, but he doesnâ€™t see himself as being in the tzeila dâ€™meheimenusa, the â€œshadow of faithâ€ that the Sukkah is. Heâ€™s doing all the mitzvos for His Master, but he hasnâ€™t yet reached emunah â€“ the sukkah that is all about emunah, recognizing Hashemâ€™s existence.
Thus, there are essentially two stages in our bond with Hashem: first we become His loyal servants by doing all his mitzvos. At a later stage in life, we must eventually enter the second, inner stage, which is to recognize Him with our emunah. These two stages are represented by two great events that our people went through: the exodus of Egypt and the Giving of the Torah. By the exodus, we were released from Pharoahâ€™s servitude and now we became servants of Hashem. By Sinai, Hashem revealed Himself with the giving of the Torah, and now we reached a new level: we recognized Hashem.
When Hashem revealed Himself by the Torah, He did not reveal Himself with His lower name, Adonoy, but rather with His higher name, Havayah. This shows us that the Torah is essentially the higher name of Hashem, Havayah.
For this reason, we never really begin to learn the actual Torah, because we are not connected to Havayah. And surely, we never finish it, for that reason. â€œThe Torah of Hashem is wholesome, it settles the soul.â€ The Baal Shem Tov said that the Torah is wholesome and perfect because no one has ever begun to learn it and complete it. What is the meaning of his statement? No one ever begun to learn the Torah?! The meaning is that the Torah throughout the generations until the end of time is not yet the actual Name of Hashem to us, and this is the deep reason why the Name of Hashem is not allowed to be pronounced.
When a person recognizes his real essence, he merits to truly learn the Torah â€“ the essence of the Torah. Through his learning, he can then come to recognize Hashem â€“ not just the actions and middos of Hashem, but an actual recognition of Hashem Himself, so to speak, in the same way that he recognizes his own essence.
Only a person who feels his own essence can come to feel the reality of Hashem. Of course, anyone will claim that he can feel himself as existing, not just a Jew, but any non-Jew as well, and even animals, can feel they exist. But as we explained, most people never arrive at true self-recognition, and they only are aware of the outer layers to their existence.
To summarize: If we want to define the purpose of Creation, the definition is clear. The purpose of Creation is to recognize the reality of Hashem. The way to get there is through self-recognition. The self is the point in a person which never ceases, for Hashem and Yisrael are one; just as Hashem is eternal, so is a soul of Yisrael eternal. If a person views himself as an entity that can cease, then in turn he views his bond with Hashem with the same superficial perspective.
The soul of a Jew is a â€œpiece of G-d from aboveâ€, and therefore, one can come to recognize Hashem through the recognition of himself. A Jew is the only nation on this world which is capable of feeling the inner self and thereby sense the Creator with just as much clarity.
This is the lesson of Sukkos: we have two mitzvos â€“ to sit in the Sukkah and to shake the Four Species. We have both of these mitzvos because we are meant to integrate both of the lessons they represent together. The Four Species represents how we must move to do all the mitzvos, the actions through which we serve our Master with. The mitzvos are the way for us to get through to our heart and reveal it. â€œThe heart is pulled after the actions.â€
What is it that we must reveal from our heart? It is not limited to the great exalted feelings of love and fear of Hashem. It is not about becoming awe-struck from elation. It is about reaching our essence, our â€œI.â€ The point of doing all the mitzvos is so that we can use all these actions to reach our Iâ€ and reveal it. In this way, we integrate Adonoy with Havayah.
The â€œIâ€ can be reached in several ways. There is way to reach it directly, but only the Kohen Gadol on Yom Kippur knew the secret of how to do it. The other way is the way which we generally take, and that is through doing all the mitzvos so that we can get through to our essence and recognize the Creator as a result. But when we do the mitzvos, the focus should not be on the actions, but rather on the goal, which is to come to our essence.
Reaching Our Point of Menuchah\Serenity
Understandably, the words here are very deep, but they are the secret about life.
All of us want grow higher and elevate ourselves. Yet, this is still a superficial approach. Itâ€™s superficial because life is not just about feeling more elated. Elation is still a kind of movement, and as we explained, movement is only the outer layer of our existence. For this reason, there is almost no one who reaches what he wants in life, because a person keeps evading his main goal, in spite of his many aspirations to grow and become more elated in spirituality.
There is a well-known parable that illustrates this message. A man dreams that there is buried treasure underneath the bridge of his town, while in reality, there is buried treasure sitting underneath his house all along.
The lesson we can learn from this is that even when a person seeks spirituality, he might very be well be running away from his real â€œtreasureâ€ all along. For example, if he thinks that Hashem is in Heaven, while he is merely on this lowly earth, then all he will know of is the mitzvos, and his entire life will be limited to performing superficial actions. The truth is that Hashem is found everywhere (Zohar III 225a) â€“ He is found inside a person! Our Avodah is to uncover our true existence, and then we will find Hashem there.
Of course, it will require a lot of â€œmovementsâ€ to get to that inner place in ourselves, but we must at least aspire to reach this point of serenity (menucha). When a person reaches menuchah in himself, Hashem is truly revealed, because menuchah represents Shabbos, the point of non-movement and a cessation from all labor. One who attains menuchah on this world can recognize the Creator, and he attains it no less than how all of us will eventually recognize Hashem in the future. But if someone never reaches the point of menuchah in himself, the â€œShabbosâ€ in himself â€“ he will not come to the recognition of the One who created the world.
 See Tanya chapter 4, and Tzidkas Hatzaddik 263.
 Iyov 19: 26
 Yalkut Shimeoni: Shemos 20: 226
 Sefer HaChinuch, 16